Graph neural networks (GNNs) are effective models for many dynamical systems consisting of entities and relations. Although most GNN applications assume a single type of entity and relation, many situations involve multiple types of interactions. Relational inference is the problem of inferring these interactions and learning the dynamics from observational data. We frame relational inference as a modular meta-learning problem, where neural modules are trained to be composed in different ways to solve many tasks. This meta-learning framework allows us to implicitly encode time invariance and infer relations in context of one another rather than independently, which increases inference capacity. Framing inference as the inner-loop optimization of meta-learning leads to a model-based approach that is more data-efficient and capable of estimating the state of entities that we do not observe directly, but whose existence can be inferred from their effect on observed entities. To address the large search space of graph neural network compositions, we meta-learn a proposal function that speeds up the inner-loop simulated annealing search within the modular meta-learning algorithm, providing two orders of magnitude increase in the size of problems that can be addressed.

This paper is quite unbalanced in two ways. Firstly the balance of space devoted to discussing background vs contributions is skewed too heavily towards discussing prior work, with too little focus on explaining the contributions of this work. Secondly, the coverage of the literature is heavily focused on graph networks and meta learning, but neglects to cover prior work on (non-graph based) modular networks and on learned proposal distributions. Towards the first imbalance, the section on lines 201-235 is by far the most important content in the paper, but is positioned almost as an afterthought to the extensive exposition of Alet et al. (2018). The paper would be much stronger if other sections were shortened and the descriptions in this region were substantially expanded (eg.

This paper is quite borderline. The reviewers were all learning towards acceptance, but none were willing to fight for the paper. The main concern for the paper is that the empirical performance gain over Kipf et al is quite small, and in some cases, non-existent. In the balance, I would put this paper slightly over the bar for acceptance. However, we strongly encourage the authors to try to better highlight the benefits over Kipf et al regarding unseen nodes, in the final version.

Graph neural networks (GNNs) are effective models for many dynamical systems consisting of entities and relations. Although most GNN applications assume a single type of entity and relation, many situations involve multiple types of interactions. Relational inference is the problem of inferring these interactions and learning the dynamics from observational data. We frame relational inference as a modular meta-learning problem, where neural modules are trained to be composed in different ways to solve many tasks. This meta-learning framework allows us to implicitly encode time invariance and infer relations in context of one another rather than independently, which increases inference capacity.

\textit{Graph neural networks} (GNNs) are effective models for many dynamical systems consisting of entities and relations. Although most GNN applications assume a single type of entity and relation, many situations involve multiple types of interactions. \textit{Relational inference} is the problem of inferring these interactions and learning the dynamics from observational data. We frame relational inference as a \textit{modular meta-learning} problem, where neural modules are trained to be composed in different ways to solve many tasks. This meta-learning framework allows us to implicitly encode time invariance and infer relations in context of one another rather than independently, which increases inference capacity. Framing inference as the inner-loop optimization of meta-learning leads to a model-based approach that is more data-efficient and capable of estimating the state of entities that we do not observe directly, but whose existence can be inferred from their effect on observed entities. To address the large search space of graph neural network compositions, we meta-learn a \textit{proposal function} that speeds up the inner-loop simulated annealing search within the modular meta-learning algorithm, providing two orders of magnitude increase in the size of problems that can be addressed.

Graph neural networks (GNNs) are effective models for many dynamical systems consisting of entities and relations. Although most GNN applications assume a single type of entity and relation, many situations involve multiple types of interactions. Relational inference is the problem of inferring these interactions and learning the dynamics from observational data. We frame relational inference as a modular meta-learning problem, where neural modules are trained to be composed in different ways to solve many tasks. This meta-learning framework allows us to implicitly encode time invariance and infer relations in context of one another rather than independently, which increases inference capacity.